"My only connection with author Frank McCourt is that he was my son's English teacher in New York City. Well, along with his best sellers, his play "The Irish and How They Got That Way" has been whipping up quite a stir in theatrical circles. Some of the reviews included in the press release are "Revue is an entertaining evening of Irish-American history in song," "Tales of the Irish dark side: McCourt revue not usual song, dance," "Revue explains 'The Irish' with warmth and wit," and so on. You will get a chance to make up your own headlines by hearing the Varese Sarabande recording featuring the Irish Repertory Theatre. Where the reviews of the actual prodctions I have read do not quite agree on the degree of accuracy of McCourt's material--some call it shallow and easygoing, others say it has a quite serious message about English suppression--they all maintain that the show provides a very enjoyable theatrical event. As a similar off-Broadway production of several years ago called "Tintypes" did for the immigrants who came into New York in the late 1800s, "The Irish" tells the tale of the Irish experience both on the Emerald Isle and on Manhattan Island in terms of the songs of the time. Many of these songs are Irish to the core: "Danny Boy," "I'll Take You Home Again, Kathleen," "Holy Ground," "Finnegan's Wake." Many have only a passing reference to the Irish labor force in America: "Erie Canal," "Workin' on the Railroad." There are 32 songs in all, most of which can be heard on the Varese Sarabande CDs. As the press release puts it: "The talented cast sing, dance and speak the words of real people who survived the devastating potato famine, emigrated to America and suffered job discrimination, then dug its canals, built its railroads, subways and sidewalks, helped fight the Civil War, battled other ethnic groups and made names in politics, the arts and songs." After agreeing with an estimate of English cooking that comes early in the script, I proceeded to enjoy greatly this recording, all the time regretting I could not appreciate the staging and what must have a good deal of sight gags as voices stretched unsuccessfully to reach high notes. All in all, a jolly romp to celebrate a nationality."
SAW THE SHOW, WORE OUT THE TAPE!
peggy.connor@eds.com | Cleveland, OH | 12/26/1998
(5 out of 5 stars)
""The Irish and How They Got That Way" was my favorite part of my New York visit. I only wish that if I went back, it would still be playing. With its' true Irish storytelling and singing, as well as the exceptional writing, even the most un-irishman would enjoy it. The soundtrack is so wonderful, I wore out the tape! Gotta love it!"
The Perfect Soundtrack for Saint Patrick's Day
John Kwok | New York, NY USA | 06/15/2001
(4 out of 5 stars)
"'Tis a wonderful potpourri of the Irish-American experience as told through song by this young, earnest cast of American and Irish actors, along with the appearance of a certain former high school teacher of mine! Those interested in hearing what the Irish-American experience has been like, will be pleasantly delighted with these songs. All of these are sung well, with great conviction (However, I've heard a far more rousing version of "Finnegan's Wake" by Tucson's The Mollys on one of their cds; the cast's rendition of "Finnegan's Wake" isn't as riveting a performance.). Personally I found the CD far more enjoyable than the video; so if you have to choose between the two, I would strongly recommend this CD. Erin go bragh!"
Dashing and entertaining way for all to learn Irish history.
John Kwok | 03/14/1999
(5 out of 5 stars)
"I haven't heard this recording yet, but i did just see the play yesterday. It was incredible!! From the moment the play opens up the viewer is drawn in as if they are part of this comical part of Irish history. The Irish... and how they got that way is truly Irish, but can be a part of any person's heart, Irish or not. The songs are all somewhat historically correct with a twist of humor that you would expect from any Irishman. A quote from the play that hit home... "As Stevenson said, 'this world is a dark, dark place... that's why the Irish are always half lit!""
Great, but the video is a 5!
James Kirby | Santa Maria, CA USA | 07/07/2000
(4 out of 5 stars)
"I must wholeheartedly agree with Peggy Connor from Cleveland.."The Irish and How They Got That Way" video soundtrack is so wonderful, I wore out the tape! In fact, I've ordered three tapes just in case!I rate the audio CD just a notch below the video because it has unexplain breaks that can only be understood if one has seen the play or the video.Also, while the entire audio cast is fantastic, I missed the pure lilting voice of Marion Tomas Griffin who was in the video in place of Donna Kane. I don't know which one was actually in the original cast. If "The Irish and how..." was ever to return to California, I would live in the theater!James Kirby"