Lorraine R. from TROY, MI Reviewed on 5/12/2007...
GREAT CD, even has Jennifer Hudson.
Amanda G. (literatec) from DES PLAINES, IL Reviewed on 8/8/2006...
A definite must for Idol favorites who left the competition far too early - Amy Adams, Matt Rogers, George Huff, etc!
CD Reviews
Actually Quite Good!
04/29/2004
(4 out of 5 stars)
"If nothing else, buy this CD to hear Camille. Her track is surprisingly good. John Stevens' voice sounds very rich in his track; it was a good choice for him. But, frankly, they're all good. I agree with the other reviewers that the ensemble track is a real treat -- it definitely proves Fantasia's and George's vocals are the most powerful (not even sure I can distinguish anyone else)."
Great except for Fantasia!
edward | Los Angeles, CA | 06/24/2004
(3 out of 5 stars)
"Everyone performs well here, even the perennially nervous Camille Velasco who seems perfect for recordings. The exception is overrated contestant Fantasia Barrino, who does nothing but squeak. Her style is sooooo annoying!"
This album's good!
fergie | Manila, Philippines | 05/04/2004
(4 out of 5 stars)
"Most of them perform as expected. The greatest surprise is Camille Velasco, who does a really wonderful job here in contrast to her disappointing numbers on the show.I wish them all luck as they embark on their respective music careers."
I love Fantasia and Camille!
harry | The 10.5 island of Los Angeles | 05/04/2004
(5 out of 5 stars)
"Yes, the girl's voice is squeaky, but she CAN sing (and sing WELL she does!)Another contestant in this album that I like is Camille. Her voice just soars in this recording; too bad that she didn't do as well in the actual competition.I think La Toya and Jasmine have realy wonderful voices. I hope that Fantasia, La Toya, and Jasmine all make it to the top three."