My Bucket's Got a Hole in It - Jimmy Page & Robert Plant
Blue Suede Shoes - Johnny Hallyday
Whole Lotta Shakin' Goin' On - Elton John
Blue Moon of Kentucky - Tom Petty
Sitting on Top of the World - Van Morrison & Carl Perkins
Don't Be Cruel - Brian Ferry
Red Cadillac and a Black Moustache - Bob Dylan
Walkin' in the Rain - Eric Clapton
Lonely Weekend - Matchbox 20
Who Will the Next Fool Be? - Sheryl Crow
It Wouldn't Be the Same Without You - Chris Isaak
I Walk the Line - Live
Drinkin' Wine Spo-Dee-O-Dee - The Howling Diablos & Kid Rock
You Win Again - Mandy Barnett with the Jordanaires
Most of the artists on this tribute to Sam Phillips's legendary Memphis label have chosen to cover the rockabilly hits. It isn't until a genuine Sun rockabilly artist--the late Carl Perkins--makes an appearance, joining Va... more »n Morrison for Howlin' Wolf's "Sittin' on Top of the World," that things briefly get bluesy. Instead, Paul McCartney, Jeff Beck, Chrissie Hynde, Tom Petty, and Bryan Ferry all offer up loving, note-for-note recreations of early Elvis tunes, even if it was Jerry Lee Lewis, not Elvis, who recorded a cover of "Don't Be Cruel" (Ferry's tune) for Sun. But Elton John and Mandy Barnett both do The Killer (Lewis) proud here, as Sheryl Crow later does for Charlie Rich, and Led Zep's Page & Plant do for Sonny Burgess. Especially marvelous is Bob Dylan's subtle and, at times, hilarious take on Warren Smith's "Red Cadillac and a Black Moustache." It's a career highlight and every bit as enchanting as Robert Gordon's '70s cover version. Like the label itself, there are more hits than misses here. --Bill Holdship« less
Most of the artists on this tribute to Sam Phillips's legendary Memphis label have chosen to cover the rockabilly hits. It isn't until a genuine Sun rockabilly artist--the late Carl Perkins--makes an appearance, joining Van Morrison for Howlin' Wolf's "Sittin' on Top of the World," that things briefly get bluesy. Instead, Paul McCartney, Jeff Beck, Chrissie Hynde, Tom Petty, and Bryan Ferry all offer up loving, note-for-note recreations of early Elvis tunes, even if it was Jerry Lee Lewis, not Elvis, who recorded a cover of "Don't Be Cruel" (Ferry's tune) for Sun. But Elton John and Mandy Barnett both do The Killer (Lewis) proud here, as Sheryl Crow later does for Charlie Rich, and Led Zep's Page & Plant do for Sonny Burgess. Especially marvelous is Bob Dylan's subtle and, at times, hilarious take on Warren Smith's "Red Cadillac and a Black Moustache." It's a career highlight and every bit as enchanting as Robert Gordon's '70s cover version. Like the label itself, there are more hits than misses here. --Bill Holdship
The Sun Shines Brightly, Despite A Few Dark Clouds
Mike King | Taunton, MA United States | 12/20/2001
(4 out of 5 stars)
""Good Rockin' Tonight" is an excellent tribute to Sun Records, marred by a few clunkers. Paul McCartney turns in an upbeat, inspired performance of "That's All Right, Mama," including more lyrics than Elvis did in his version. Elton John passionately pounds the piano and does his best Jerry Lee Lewis style vocal on "Whole Lotta Shakin' Goin' On." It's Elton's rockingest performance in years and my favorite track. Bob Dylan performs the obscure Warren Smith tune "Red Cadillac And A Black Moustache" in his unique style and remakes it into a Dylan classic. Like a fine wine, Dylan gets better with age. Bryan Ferry turns in a polished performance of "Don't Be Cruel". It wasn't a hit for Elvis until his RCA years, but Jerry Lee Lewis recorded a version of the song while he was at Sun records. Sheryl Crow does a bluesy version of the Charlie Rich classic "Who Will The Next Fool Be?", while Matchbox 20 rocks the house with a lively version of Mr. Rich's "Lonely Weekend." "It Wouldn't Be The Same Without You" is an obscure track that appeared on the Elvis "Sunrise" compilation. Chris Isaak sounds so much like a young Elvis that his version of the song could be mistaken for an outtake from "Sunrise." On the other hand, Live turn in an off-key performance of "I Walk The Line" which can't compare to the original Johnny Cash classic. The Howling Diablos and Kid Rock should be arrested for murdering the song "Drinkin' Wine Spo-Dee-O-Dee." They single-handedly prevented me from giving "Good Rockin' Tonight" a five star rating."
Not The Usual 'Tribute' Sludge
Peter Savage | Near Portland, ME USA | 12/26/2001
(5 out of 5 stars)
"I usually hate these kinds of records -- recent duds include 'A Nod To Bob' and the 'Avalon Blues' collection. But this is in a class of its own. Paul McCartney's version of "That's Alright, Mama" is a fine opener, with assistance from Scottie Moore and DJ Fontana from the original 1955 session. Jeff Beck is amazing on "Mystery Train," conjuring up licks from every era of rockabilly. Chrissie Hynde, though, sounds as though she is having a gastric attack. The Page/Plant track is so-so, but Johnny Halliday's "Blue Suede Shoes" makes up for it. The Dylan "Red Cadillac" is amusing, if a bit strained. But the highspots are Sheryl Crowe's track, "Who Will The Next Fool Be?" (surely a Clapton guitar role here?), Matchbox 20 on "Lonely Weekend" and Kid Rock, et al., on "Drinking Wine SpohdeeOhDee".I'm old enough to remember the originals, and most of this CD is right up to standard. It was a shock to hear Carl Perkins with Van Morrison (obviously an older track), but it's a treat to hear him play some perfect guitar licks in the coda...Oh, and Elton John's "Whole Lotta Shaking" is really cool..."
Some cool stuff here, some not so cool stuff too
Susan T. | 12/01/2001
(4 out of 5 stars)
"what you see is what you're gonna get....the older artists on this cd (van morrison, mccartney, dylan, page, beck, clapton) stay truer to the sun sound than the newer artists (kid rock, matchbox 20, live). i personally like the truer-sounding artists better--i don't care about these newer bands' interpretations of classic tunes. but to each his or her own. it's cool to hear mccartney sing "that's all right" and clapton stands out with "walking in the rain." the dylan tune is wonderful, as is the hynde/jeff beck collaboration. if nothing else, if you don't own any of the original sun recordings, go get some!!"
Just saw the PBS special - Great except for 1
Susan T. | 11/29/2001
(4 out of 5 stars)
"Everyone did a tremendous job of recreating this great collection of music, but whose lame idea was it to invite Kid Rock and his entourage? Sorry, but the stuff just doesn't fit here. I was going to buy this CD but that song really killed it for me. Live does a tremendous rendition of I Walk the Line. What a talented group of guys and I have never really heard their music before. And of course, who doesn't love Rob Thomas and Matchbox Twenty. It was great to hear Robert Plant and Jimmy Page again. It's so cool to see all the different generations collaborate on a common music form. I recall listening to Led Zeppelin in the '70s and my parents hated the music - thought is was loud and distasteful. Now I look at Plant and Page and they are both older than my parents were then, and they're still rocking! I always considered it young people's music then because it sort of was. Obviously, it isn't anymore! Nice to see the transformation of the music across generations like that. Ben Folds Five was great as well although their tune didn't make this CD. Maybe they could have cut the Kid Rock tune and slipped in the Ben Folds Five tune. But, Paul McCartney's rendition of That's All Right Mama is the best! Anyway, I would have given this 5 stars if it weren't for that Kid Rock cut but aside from that one, the CD is a winner."