Brian M Small | Londonderry, NH United States | 12/30/2001
(1 out of 5 stars)
"Ever wonder what U2 would sound like with a different lead singer? This disc should answer that question. The only song I can recommend at all is Desire because of it's slightly more blues bar feel but it's still too much like the original. Buy only if you have money to burn."
Horrible
flash148 | United States | 12/28/2001
(1 out of 5 stars)
"No tribute here, same band does all the songs (Irish Rock Association) and does em exactly as U2 does em, just a cover band, no tribute, Don't get fooled by this!"
"NOT" Even Better then the Real Thing
noone42 | 05/02/2003
(1 out of 5 stars)
"Well, I guess you can give a little credit to the "Various Artists" (I noticed no variations) for being brave enough to try and cover U2 songs(and no, I would not call this a tribute). However, I am not in a mood to be kind. U2 is a great band. Everything clicks with them. Nothing can change that and while the lyrics are still great, the songs are butchered. The singer does nothing but try and imitate Bono's wonderfully raspy voice and ends up sounding like a chainsaw. I can do a better job singing them in the shower. The music is loud and distracting. The Edge, Larry Mullen Jr and Adam Clayton, I imagine, would be horrified. A band that just started playing together a couple of weeks ago could do better. You get the idea. Given how dreadful it is, I am glad I borrowed a copy from a friend. I would highly recommend not throwing your money away on this. Go and buy the real deal, because nothing can compare."
Why Bother?
C. Hultberg | Erie, PA United States | 12/10/2001
(2 out of 5 stars)
"I'm not sure why you would bother to cover these songs if you are going to play them the exact way they are written. I prefer cover tunes to be done with originality. Its a tribute album! Put some passion into it."
What Various Artists?
dhogan78 | Scotch Plains, NJ United States | 12/14/2001
(1 out of 5 stars)
"In all fairness, I must say right off the bat that I have not listened to this album, only to the samples provided on this page. That being said, if this counts as a "tribute to U2" I should start recording my shower singing and sell that. Amazon doesn't list who these "Various Artists" are, but to me it sounds like the same guy doing a very bad Bono imitation on every track. The music itself sounds like it came from a karaoke machine, and like the vocals, it is a souless note for note, inflection for inflection copy in every way, down to the double tracking of the vocals on Discotheque. Pop your favorite U2 songs on the car stereo and sing along, you'll get more feeling out of it and probably sound better too."