Search - Various Artists :: Tributo a Jose Alfredo Jimenez XXX

TRIBUTO AL DESASTRE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

jerardo soto | TOLEDO, OH. United States | 02/25/2004

(2 out of 5 stars)

"Creo que este tributo pudo ser mucho mejor, la verdad cuenta con demasiadas participaciones, que termina siendo casi un desastre musical, una verdadera lastima porque las canciones de uno de los mejores compositores mexicanos, JOSE ALFREDO JIMENEZ, no se merecia este casi desastre musical, se puede ver claramente que el objetivo de la disquera era vender el producto a toda costa, lo cual me parece bastante ridiculo a estas alturas, cuando se han generado millones de ventas de los discos de jose alfredo, bueno retomando las participaciones que me parecen bastante buenas y recomendables son: JUMBO/LA LUNA, MOENIA, SAUL Y ELEFANTE,BUNBURY, este ultimo fue removido de la edicion de estados unidos, que me parece bastante mal, que lastima que este tributo no sea como el de hace cuatro anos atras a jose jose, bastante malo, mejor escuchenlo antes de comprarlo."

Not complete - it originally has 20 songs

demayor | North Hollywood, CA USA | 02/18/2004

(4 out of 5 stars)

"I was actually desapointed that the US version of this album did not include all 20 songs that originally has in the Mexican and Latin American version.

To me the most impressive version of a Jose Alfredo Jimenezsong has been made by Enrique Bunbury. He has performed this song since 1997 and has closed most of his concerts with it. It has now become a clasic of his shows. The live version included originally in the mexican version of this album is the best of all 20 songs.

Other than that, this album is great. All the musicians did a great job bringing back to life the songs of this great writer."