El mejor de los Requiem Renacentistas Hispanos
P. Alvarez | Killeen, Texas United States | 04/02/2005
(5 out of 5 stars)
"Una obra sublime, brillante
llena del misticismo y el
fervor Hispanico. Este es
uno de los mejores "Officium
Defunctorum" proveniente de Espana.
Tomas Luis de Victoria es uno
de los mejores exponentes del arte
musical sacro, lo que lo hace uno
los miembros de "La triada Espanola"
los otros dos compositores son Guerrero
y Morales. El Requiem de 1603 de Tomas
Luis de VIctoria fue compuesto para las
exequias de la emperatriz Maria de Austria.
En esta grabaccion el director Paul McCreesh
nos presenta la obra como fue presentada en
las exequias de la emperatriz, el director
incluye algunos cantos gregorianos asi como
lo hizo Victoria en aquel entonces, tal
practica colabora a completar la liturgia.
Este es un disco de maxima recomendaccion
el conjunto Gabrielli Consort hace
un trabajo formidable..."
Great Singing, Annoying Format and Recording Job
Timothy Dougal | Madison, Wi United States | 03/08/2002
(4 out of 5 stars)
"This disc of the "Requiem" contains some of the best singing I have ever heard, and the interpretation of Victoria's music is unmatched for dramatic intensity. However, (and for me these are significant howevers), both the presentation and recording job are problematic. Like many of McCreesh's recordings, this is a reconstruction. If you have never been at a Catholic high Mass in the old style, or are a liturgical historian, it may be interesting, once or twice, to hear the context in which the "Requiem" originally was heard. That being said, though, the ordinary chants, including the chanted readings, are frankly ordinary, utilitarian, tedious, and of minimal musical interest. The one exception here is the "Dies Irae", sung in its entirety. All told, you have to program out about 25% of this disc to listen to just the Victoria music. The other caveat is that for some reason the sibilant sounds, and the t's and p's, are REALLY prominent in the mix. If you've got equipment that can minimize this, you're way ahead, sonically."
Haunting...stunningly beautiful singing.
Anton Karidian | Toronto | 01/06/2002
(5 out of 5 stars)
"The all male chorus of the Gabrielli Consort under the direction of McCreesh sing with impeccable beauty. The ethereal quality apt for a Requiem setting is perfectly realized conveying effectively a pious reverent quality suitable for this piece."