Catch the Vines in studio, not in concert
12/22/2003
(3 out of 5 stars)
"The Vines' unquestionable genius is much more apparent on their studio album "Highly Evolved" than it is on any of the live recordings I have heard (plus the concert I attended). This version of "Mary Jane" is no different; a mediocre recording by a band that appears to lack the desire to put on a really good show. The layers of dreamy piano and guitar and the lush vocals on the studio recording won't be found here; nor will the excitement and earnestness of what should be found in a live performance make up for what is lacking here. "Highly Evolved" is my favorite album in ten years, and has had the number one spot in my cd player for ages. The sad truth is, though, that you should go for their studio recordings before their live recordings (one exception: "Get Free" on the "Outathaway" single). Try their studio cover of "Ms. Jackson", also found on another edition of the "Outtathaway" single."