"Sorry, but if it ain't got Jimmy Hall, it ain't Wet Willie!!!"
Hum Drum
Matthew L. Higley | Utah | 03/23/2005
(2 out of 5 stars)
"The lead singer's voice is not as full as Jimmy's voice, they play the songs a little faster than normal. Jimmy's southern drawl just makes the music sound better, when he sings. I have seen the original band in concert with a horn section and the willettes as the backing vocals' and the concert was done right after they did their last record album. For me being a hard core fan of Wet Willie and if you are a hard core fan of Wet Willie.I DO NOT recommend this CD highly.It's not worth it."
Which One's Willie?
AJ82 | Ohio | 07/22/2005
(4 out of 5 stars)
"Probably the hardest thing a band can go through is replacing the lead vocalist. Only a few groups have had some success with this - Van Halen, Chicago and Bad Company. And usually there are the die-hards that remain faithful to the original line-up and dismiss the band. In this case, the lead singer is not Jimmy Hall - and Jimmy had a very distinct vocal style and sound - he's probably one of the best Southern style vocalists around. The vocalist here has a very New Orleans (or cajun) sound - and while he's not Jimmy - he doesn't pretend to be him either. He does a very capable job with the material. The recording quality/mixing is very good and the audience is not over-bearing. Most important, it's great to hear the band get out and perform once again. I would have given the album 5 stars but 3 key songs (in my eyes) are missing - "Weekend", "Make You Feel Love Again" and "Rainman" (by Michael Duke). The last two songs from the fantastic "Manorisms" album. With the current release of Wet Willie's Epic Record albums on a single disc - that's probably the better route to go. But I must say that this is a very good release and would definitely hunt it down, especially on the used market!"
Vocals not the Biggest problem!
E. Voorhies | United States | 01/23/2006
(2 out of 5 stars)
"I've been a Wet Willie fan since I saw them in Memphis back in the late 70's. I've just listened to the clips of this CD and while I grant that the vocals fall far short of Jimmy Hall's, they are not the biggest problem by a long shot. The guitar tone is so thin and trebly it sounds like he's plugged into a transistor radio with a blown 2 inch speaker and turned it up full blast! This may be the worst sounding live electric guitar tone I've ever heard and I've heard a lot. What the heck's going on here. Are the sound engineer's eardrums busted from years of mixing rock n roll?"