Search - White Willow :: Signal to Noise

Kenneth W. (Eyesore) from TAUNTON, MA
Reviewed on 12/4/2007...

These days Norway's White Willow is always placed into the prog-rock category; but "progressive" seems to be a bit of a misnomer for this band. Their early material is rooted in a more folk-rock melancholia whereas they began to explore a slightly heavier -- relatively speaking -- more progressive sound on their third album, Storm Season. They've undoubtedly always had progressive tendencies, but they fall in line with latter day The Gathering with a slightly more dreamy, atmospheric pop sound. That sort of description may turn some people off, but Signal To Noise has far more depth than the picture that simple verbal sketch suggests. Like the post-Nighttime Birds material from The Gathering, White Willow wistfully wanders through ethereal soundscapes on Signal To Noise.

The music offered here is a mix of progressive rock, light electronica, gothic shoegaze, folk, and pop musings. New vocalist Trude Eidtang adds another layer with her sweet, airy, and engaging vocals, a style that seems right at home floating over the myriad shifting musical currents. "Night Surf" opens the album. It's a slow- to mid-paced song punctuated by flute and lithe electronic effects, minimal guitar work, and a captivating vocal performance by Eidtang. "Splinters" and "Ghosts" follow a similar path, though the latter does so without vocals. Comparisons to The Gathering are reinforced through the first three tracks, but with the fourth track, "Joyride," the band places a solid wedge between themselves and The Gathering, and any other progressive rock band or comparison, opting for a more dream pop style similar to something you'd hear from Emm Gryner or Box The Walls. "The Lingering" is an outstanding 9-minute opus of melancholic darkness, the heaviest number on the album. White Willow's folk-rock roots are laid bare on "The Dark Road" and the instrumental "Chrome Dawn," while "Dusk City" is easily the most traditional progressive rock-sounding song on Signal To Noise. A short, quiet instrumental called "Ararat" ends the album on a less-than-powerful note, considering the kind of imagery the word Ararat invokes.

White Willow can be a tough act to indulge in, especially for a strict progressive rock/metal fan. The emotions that Signal To Noise evokes while listening to the album can put the listener ill at ease, because there is no emotional theme presented throughout the album. One song is a dark, poetic display of sorrow, while the next has a pop bounce or a folk-like lilt that kind of tosses the album around on its axis a bit. But if you give Signal To Noise a good once-over with an open mind you may find something very enjoyable. Prog-rock sticklers should avoid White Willow since the progressive part of their music is a very deep undercurrent.

Website: http://www.whitewillow.org
MySpace: http://www.myspace.com/whitewillowband

Very Pleased

IcemanJ | Ohio, USA | 11/04/2006

(5 out of 5 stars)

"I've loved White Willow from the first note I heard. And I am proud to say that this album doesn't change that. I didn't like "Storm Season," as much as all the other albums. It explored a little darker and heavier side of the band, which was nice for something different, but the heaviness and more aggressive singing didn't feel natural for the band. I'm glad they didn't go farther into that direction. This album gets away from that a little and revisits their more melodic side, although some aggressiveness still lingering especially in the first track, "Night Surf."



The Instrumentation includes many Keyboards, mellotrons, and mini-moogs as usual, also some woodwinds, and grand piano. Now to be completely honest, I had no idea there was a new vocalist until I saw it mentioned. Trude Eidtang has as wonderful a voice as Sylvia Erichsen, not to mention they sound quite similar.



On every one of their albums there has been at least one song that is especially enchanting, something out of this world, something while listening you wonder just how they possibly came up with something so brilliant. On this album, originally, I believed that song was "Splinters." This is a softer song for the most part, with a slightly heavier chorus; the vocal melodies pierce through the soft keyboard melodies and send chills down your spine.



After a month or so of many listens, "Joyride" seems like the best song here. The title is very fitting, because from the first instant, this is one of the most Joyful tunes I have ever heard. It really is a Joyride. "The Dark Road" is probably my third favorite song, similarly brimming with enormously blissful harmonies, except it is slower paced.



Like I said, I'm very pleased with this album especially after the previous one. If you like White Willow be sure to check out Paatos, Pineforest Crunch, and Anglagard."