Search - Who :: The 1st Singles Box

Ick. Extortionist package misses all of the bases

David Goodwin | Westchester, NY United States | 05/29/2004

(1 out of 5 stars)

"Someone, *please* answer this question: to whom is this set supposed to be attractive? Collectors have these songs. Neophytes can get them elsewhere. The Stones' singles box was at least somewhat moderately priced, and have a wealth of fetishistic packaging; this is hilariously expensive, and...and...Oh, I don't know.That the Who's reissue campaign started wonderfully and quickly descended into a misguided, poor-quality ego-fest (Live at Leeds Deluxe, anyone?) is almost canon by this point. This set shows that it's VERY possible to indeed sink farther into the hole. It's a singles collection, alright, of one of the principal 60s' singles bands, yet it manages to steadfastly *avoid* singles that include songs the reissue campaign missed (where's The Relay? When I Was a Boy? Here For More?). And rarities? Pah. We don't get any. *Everything* here, if I've got this right, has been released on CD previously; we don't even get the original single mixes of I Can See for Miles (stereo!) or Happy Jack (fake stereo!) tossed our way. The sound quality is generally fairly abysmal.Verdict? If done right, this set could've filled a niche. It doesn't. It sounds awful, contains nothing of even remote interest to collectors, and is just another entry in the Who's endless, misguided compilation-athon. Oh well. Avoid like the plague."

One for the fans

Anthony Guagliardo | New York | 05/31/2004

(5 out of 5 stars)

"I bought this box set for $60 at Tower and I'm very happy with it. It's not meant to be a greatest hits package or to fill in any holes in your collection. All of the material here is available elsewhere. No, this box is strictly for collectors. Each disc comes in an exact, cd-sized replica sleeve of the original 45. And not just sleeves from UK and US. Pictures of Lily comes in the French sleeve, Happy Jack the Norwegian sleeve, I Can See For Miles - Japanese, etc. The Who did right by fans with this box set. It's a thing of beauty. As for the new songs, they're very good. It's great to hear Daltrey giving voice to Townshend's lyrics again. For the first time in decades their hearts are in it and it's palpable. If you're expecting Who's Next 2004 though you're in for a disappointment. These guys are 60. They've matured and so has their music. Old Red Wine and Real Good Looking Boy is where they are now. Dig it."